[IPSM] 10:10:10 and 350.org: Marketing, Manipulation, and the Status Quo
Macdonald Stainsby
mstainsby at resist.ca
Fri Oct 8 10:36:23 PDT 2010
10:10:10 and 350.org: Marketing, Manipulation, and the Status Quo
08 October 2010
Gregory Vickrey with Cory Morningstar
As we stand on the edge of apocalypse, we must wake up and acknowledge
what the big greens are not saying is far more important than what they
are saying. Excerpts from a controversial new book to be released
2010-2011. Article one in a series, we discuss the connection between
environmental campaigns and their corporate sponsors.
“The good intentions of participants of 350.org aside, requesting world
leaders to reduce carbon emissions is unfortunately not going to work.
Bill McKibben asserts that world leaders will listen “if we’re loud
enough,” but that’s simply untrue. If we stick with symbolic action, the
destruction will become progressively worse, and we will continuously
lose ground and be reduced to begging for mercy that will never be
granted. Those in power (and their political representatives) will only
stop destroying the planet if they are forced to do so. The immediate
threat of social disorder and economic disruption will make them listen.
An immediate and serious threat to their wealth and well-being will make
them listen.” - Stephanie McMillan, Code Green
Understanding 10:10:10
All big greens and little greens alike are
promoting the latest climate change campaign, 10:10:10, on the front
page of every website and in every email. Two of the main promoters of
350.org’s 10:10:10 ‘Global Work Party’ are none other than corporate
darling TckTckTck and, of course, Greenpeace International. Making the
intimate link between the two, Kumi Naidoo is the Executive Director of
the organization and chairs the Global Campaign for Climate Action, the
group behind TckTckTck.
The escalating climate crisis - scientists now refer to it as the ‘6th
extinction’ - has now been transformed to a party.
10:10:10 states, “A strong and vibrant climate movement will create the
political space for our champions to lead; take-on the big polluters and
bought-off politicians who are blocking progress; and help us implement
innovative climate solutions from the ground up.” Completely ignoring
the intent of their own rhetoric, some of the top ideas on the 10:10:10
website for the party are: organize a tree planting, work on a community
garden or an organic farm, go for a bike ride, or do a trash cleanup.
Once again, the emphasis of this latest symbolic big green campaign
avoids the root causes of climate change; the current state of
accelerating climate change according to the latest science; the false
solutions being sold as just goods; and a stark, deafening silence on
the People’s Agreement constructed in Cochabamba, Bolivia, April 2010.
(It is important to note here that this is the only agreement to date
that has the potential to save humanity from suicidal extinction. This
last, despite 350.org’s presence in Cochabamba, with its own
representatives positioned as ‘presidents’ of several working groups.)
The 10:10:10 campaign does not demand that all nations and all
non-government organizations (NGOs) formally acknowledge the world is
far beyond dangerous interference with the climate system. Why not?
Leading scientist John Holdren has been explaining this since 2006.
Holdren is advisor to President Barack Obama for Science and Technology,
Director of the White House Office of Science and Technology Policy, and
Co-Chair of the President’s Council of Advisors on Science and
Technology. The 10:10:10 campaign does not demand that nations and NGOs
declare a global climate state of emergency. Why not? NASA climate
scientist James Hansen has appealed for such a declaration since 2008.
Further, the International Panel on Climate Change (IPCC) states that
civil society must be the organ to make this declaration – yet those who
claim to represent civil society -- as 350.org often does -- spew
rhetoric instead of reality.
Nature’s Razor
The greatest danger to survival of life lies within combined Arctic
feedback cycles, all of which are now operational. None of the climate
models used by IPCC include any of the Arctic feedbacks below. This
makes all projections of potential increase in global temperature, as
well as any contrived limits on human emissions, dangerously misleading.
Arctic sea ice volume has reached the lowest level ever recorded,
prompting the director of the National Snow & Ice Data Center in
Boulder, Colorado, Mark Serreze, to state, "The Arctic summer sea ice
cover is in a death spiral. It's not going to recover...I hate to say it
but I think we are committed to a four- to sixdegree warmer Arctic.”
Methane release from melting permafrost is the most dangerous amplifying
feedback in the carbon cycle. Earlier this year we were witness to a
science stunner. Scientists found that the vast Siberian Arctic shelf
methane stores are now destabilizing and venting. National Science
Foundation issued our world a wake-up call: “Release of even a fraction
of the methane stored in the shelf could trigger abrupt climate warming.”
Scientists have discovered that the seas are acidifying ten times faster
today than 55 million years ago when a mass extinction of marine species
occurred. The increasing acidity reduces the amounts of calcium
carbonate available to plankton and other species which require it to
form shells and skeletons. Studies show phytoplankton have died off more
than 40% since 1950 and continue to do so at an accelerating rate. “This
is an almost unprecedented geological event,” states Andy Ridgwell, an
earth scientist at the University of Bristol.
Making matters significantly worse for humanity, food security manifests
itself as a second state of emergency intimately connected with climate.
The worst ever environmental and health catastrophe is now inevitable,
and we must render a comprehensive global emergency response. Nations
and NGOs who refuse to acknowledge destructive climate interference and
the inherent state of global climate emergency are, in effect,
supporting and perpetuating the status quo: a general state of denial
of, and inaction toward, the worst crime ever committed against humanity.
In the presence of fact and a recognizable path to global extinction,
the only target that now matters is zero carbon. To save humanity,
fossil fuels must be completely abandoned. Every other target, without
distinction, leads to irreversible climate catastrophe.
Yet we are told to throw a global day of action for 24 hours each year
(this year, 10:10:10), no matter the challenges science purports and
reality verifies. And somehow this party will grow into a new movement
to take on these challenges, and this reality that no one discusses.
Symbolism must be an omnipotent force. “Get to Work” - 350.org
“One of the truest tests of integrity is its blunt refusal to be
compromised.” – Chinua Achebe – Nigerian Writer
For too long, the environmental movement - led by the big greens - has
locked the climate movement into a two-pronged strategy comprised of
lobbying partisan, corrupt politicians, and climbing into bed with any -
and nearly every - corporate power, in the pursuit of symbolic
victories, the ecstasy of the illusion of power, and to integrate the DC
cocktail circuit. Even in this, the movement has failed. After the
largest oil spill in history earlier this year, the movement and its
most powerful leaders did not call for a ban on all offshore drilling;
instead, they urged citizens to demand a temporary moratorium on new
offshore drilling. Having no ability in the art of negotiation, and
displaying an approach that was sophomoric, at best, they failed to
properly secure the half-solution they sought, and the loopholes
continue the cataclysmic trends that existed before the Deepwater
Horizon entered our consciousness. Epic fail.
Nearly two decades after the first climate convention in Rio, global
emissions are up over 40% and planetary boundaries are being crossed. We
now stand on the cusp of humanity’s most dangerous moment. For those two
decades the big greens have been flirting and sleeping with the enemy,
and no matter their willingness are still shamed come morning, because
the BPs of the world are welcome to plant their decadent seed in any of
the big greens, and the governments around the globe besides, without
any recourse.
What more evidence do we need to see in order to accept that backroom
lobbying and symbolic campaigning has not worked and will not work?
“Politically feasible.”
“Politically possible.”
“Reasonable.”
“The best we can get.”
“Win-win.”
Big greens can’t yet comprehend the concept of morning remorse. It takes
a spine to accept the guilt. Fossil fuels must be completely abandoned.
We have already stated that, from the perspective of reality. Let us say
it again. Fossil fuels must be completely abandoned. Nature won’t be
giving us a pat on the back or boost our resumes for what we deem
politically feasible, and the physics of nature is not about to come to
the table for negotiations on entropy. Better is not better when better
still means dead. Massive climate emergency movements in every country
are the only forces with the potential to drive politicians toward
effective action against greenhouse gas emissions. That is the only way
to win time for our Earth - and ourselves.
Symbolism
“It is an utterly pointless task trying to make Industrial Civilization
sustainable or “environmentally friendly”, because the nature of
civilization is to destroy, to take what it wants to achieve its aims
and only stop when it runs out of energy, people or space. It only stops
when it collapses – it never stops of its own accord.” - Keith Farnish,
the Unsuitablog
Thus, we find ourselves in yet another bizarre situation and ready to
party on 10:10:10 with international climate change organization
TckTckTck; with Greenpeace; with 350.org; with World Wildlife Federation
(WWF); with more than 350 other dance partners; and, not without
significance, with Havas Worldwide, the world’s sixth largest
advertising company, and creator of the TckTckTck campaign. Havas
clients include Wal-Mart, Coca-Cola, Pfizer, BP and several other
multinational conglomerates who indiscriminately rape and pillage our
Earth, while exploiting the most vulnerable communities, cultures, and
societies around the globe, in exchange for nothing more than financial
profits and cash windfalls, seeking infinite gains on a finite planet.
When we fight multinationals, we call them corporate criminals. When we
take their money, we call them partners.
The climate change movement is said to oppose oil giants controlled by
Rockefeller and friends. Yet the foundations and charities of
Rockefeller and friends generously fund progressive environmentalists
with the purpose being to ultimately oversee and influence various and
significant activities. Recall the fairytale in which the witch
decorates her home as a gingerbread house in order to entice the
children inside and ultimately cook them to kibble in a pot of boiling
water. We are those children – and we are being manipulated to admire
the grand illusion of democracy set before us as we march as one towards
our own demise.
Not so bad, says 10:10:10 and friends. We can throw a party along the
way, and the conscientious among us can pre-order caskets made of green,
sustainable bamboo manufactured in a Chinese sweatshop.
Last year, on 350.org’s Global Day of Action (October 24, 2009),
TckTckTck was shiny, new and present. In Canada, on Parliament Hill,
between 1,000 and 2,000 people assembled throughout the morning and
afternoon. The crowd received instructions to move apart, and
individuals were then told reach their hands to the sky and pretend they
were clocks. Next, they were told to chant “TckTckTck!” while rotating
arms in analog fashion. TckTckTck ... TckTckTck … faster! Faster! It is
no stretch of the imagination to envision Havas and their corporate CEO
friends - friends who push for more nuclear power, more genetic
engineering, more cloning, more water privatization, more growth, more
consumption - sitting back and laughing their asses off at those of us
at Parliament Hill and all around the globe that day, people-clocks
chanting their corporate branded slogan TckTckTck as the world burned.
Denialism
Big greens want us to believe that we will fall into a pit of despair
once we accept the situation as dire and will become immobilized. Is
this true? No. In fact, history demonstrates time and time again that
when faced with cataclysmic emergencies, people and communities pull
together. Facing disaster, citizens of nations have shown they can unite
for the common good. Sure, when we face the facts that now exist,
despair is only human. The question is whether acknowledging our
circumstances will immobilize us or give us the truth we need to face a
daunting task. Philosopher Friedrich Nietzsche distinguished between
what he called the “pessimism of strength” and the “pessimism of
weakness”. “Pessimism of weakness” means succumbing to apathy in the
face of overwhelming odds. “Pessimism of strength” means facing up to
the facts, acknowledging the danger fully, and making a decision about
how best to act. In other words, fear is good, and these parameters
define our sense of responsibility.
Big greens are certainly aware that we are now in a death-spiral brought
about by the capitalist, consumptive, and corporate domination of
society. Yet they actively choose to remain muzzled on the subject.
Power structures in place today do not act, and never will act, to stop
climate change, because the changes so desperately needed by those most
vulnerable on the planet are in direct conflict to the needs and
rapacious desires of capital. Capital has no empathy. Capital has no
children to love and protect. Capital has only one imperative, and that
is to grow. Under the current economic system, the penultimate measure
of success is profit. Corporations exist to maximize profits while
externalizing costs. That is their nature. They cannot behave otherwise.
Spewing greenhouse gases, toxins, and chemicals into the environment is
a fundamental feature of capitalism employed by modern corporations and
governments, and accounts for most of the pollutants directed into our
air, water, and earth. Waste, pollution, and ecological destruction are
built into the system.
Retribution
“Nemesis was the Greek goddess of retribution. She exacted divine
punishment on arrogant mortals who believed they could defy the gods,
turn themselves into objects of worship and build ruthless systems of
power to control the world around them. The price of such hubris was
almost always death. Nemesis, related to the Greek word némein, means
“to give what is due.” Our nemesis fast approaches. We will get what we
are due. The staggering myopia of our corrupt political and economic
elite, which plunder the nation’s wealth for financial speculation and
endless war, the mass retreat of citizens into virtual hallucinations,
the collapsing edifices around us, which include the ecosystem that
sustains life, are ignored for a giddy self-worship.” - September 27th,
2010. Chris Hedges, TruthDig.
Are we ready for such reflection? Is it past time to start talking about
the core issues, the root causes of climate change? Is it past time to
start questioning why those who claim to speak for civil society refuse
to discuss these very issues?
The most provocative tool for comprehending abject behavior we have
learned as climate justice activists is this: when issues are not being
tackled by directly addressing the root of the problem, one must ask why.
To answer this question, this “why”, we have discovered there is one
tactic which uncovers more information than any other single tactic.
It is this:
Follow the money.
Funding 10:10:10
This 350.org project, 10:10:10, in whole or in part, is funded by Global
Greengrants Fund (GGF), an entity which works with, and receives funding
from, the Rockefeller Brothers Foundation and others, including ‘1% for
the Planet’ (slogan: “Keep Earth in Business”). On July 21, 2010, GGF
announced a partnership with 350.org: “Greengrants is excited to launch
a new initiative of the Greengrants Climate Fund: the 350 Project Fund.
Led by 350.org, the campaign to build a global movement for climate
solutions, this initiative builds momentum and funds for climate
solutions worldwide.” Who is Global Greengrants? GGF states: “Our
advisers and partners are currently focusing on REDD and REDD+ efforts
around climate mitigation. REDD stands for ‘Reducing Emissions from
Deforestation and (forest) Degradation’. It is one of the areas of
discussion at COP15 where some believe the most positive movement was made.”
In fact, REDD is one of the most contentious false solutions being
fought by Indigenous peoples and grassroots climate activists all over
the world. GGF has announced that through the establishment of their new
pro-REDD ‘Climate Fund’, they were, and remain, involved in sponsoring
delegates to United Nations Framework Convention on Climate Change
conferences such as COP15. This has proven to be a very successful
formula for ensuring that anti-REDD Indigenous voices have been silenced
from international conferences and climate talks, conveying to the
general public the falsehood that REDD has been embraced far and wide.
Those with no financial means to attend COP quite effectively have their
mouths gagged and therefore become invisible on the global stage.
Those who agree with false solutions continue to be funded. Those who do
not are replaced. From the Rockefeller site:
RBF grantee Sustainable Markets Foundation's 350.org launched its new
web site, gearing up for "10/10/ 10, the Global Work Party" on October
10, 2010. Organizers are encouraging individuals worldwide to do
something to combat global warming in their communities. More than a
thousand groups in over 100 countries already have registered their
events with 350.org, which include a bicycle repair day in New Zealand,
planting thousands of trees in Uganda, and installing solar stoves for a
carbon-neutral picnic in Bolivia.
These are all nice events, and are likely being organized by
well-intentioned individuals. Unfortunately, none of them - or any
semblance of them - will save us from catastrophic climate change.
Has the climate crisis (d)evolved into a mere Earth Day event to be held
on an annual basis - a festive party to be celebrated? The symbolic
Earth Hour, organized by industrial nonprofit complex World Wildlife
Foundation (WWF), is now held each spring. 350.org a.k.a. Sustainable
Markets Foundation a.k.a. 350.org Project a.k.a. 10:10:10 now claims a
global climate party in the fall. Perhaps if we participate in Earth
Hour or the Global Day of Action (or both!), and recycle our cans,
bottles, and paper products at home, we can all feel we did our part
until next year.
The Rockefellers certainly would like us to think so.
The Rockefeller family – think big oil (as big as oil gets) – is another
primary funder of 350.org (Sustainable Markets Foundation). The
Rockefellers, with other members of the plutocracy such as the Clinton
family, were also instrumental in the creation of 1Sky, sister of
350.org. An organization which pushes false solutions and grossly
inadequate climate legislation under the guise of ‘grassroots’
democracy, 1Sky is a prime example of an NGO created for the power
elite. It operates as a think tank where past, present, and future
policy analysts, high-ranking government officials, business leaders and
CEOs, intellectuals, journalists, and conservative activists come
together to develop political vision and strategy. Many
well-intentioned, well-respected individuals are manipulated into
lending their involvement to such institutes, which in turn lends
credibility to 1Sky, 350.org, and their ilk when they deserve none. We
would like to name every foundation and corporate entity that funds
350.org and 10:10:10, and how many hundreds of thousands of dollars they
receive to implement the tactics of manipulation put forth by their
corporate partners, but they choose not to respond to our requests for
information. Likewise, they refuse to share the information on their
websites, or in any other public forum.
Why it Matters
“It’s difficult to get a man to understand something if his salary
depends upon his not understanding it.” Upton Sinclair
Whether directly or indirectly, industry and industry-linked foundations
steer environmental organizations away from grassroots movements and
create an elite-structured caviar class of environmentalists financially
motivated to pursue 'business as usual' solutions. Today there is a
deafening silence as well as cries for censorship on this critical
topic, even within the climate justice movement itself. Silence kills
and silence is complicity in the escalating climate disruption, climate
emergency and climate genocide that is predicted to kill billions this
century. Earth and paleoclimate scientist, Dr. Andrew Glikson of the
Australian National University states that “informed people are now
staring into the abyss”. Pablo Eisenberg at Georgetown University’s
Public Policy Institute has stated, “although we know that our
socioeconomic, ecological, and political problems are interrelated, a
growing portion of our nonprofit world nevertheless continues to operate
in a way that fails to reflect this complexity and connectedness.” This
unwillingness to confront the broader issues of climate change such as
militarism, livestock, and the capitalistic practices inherent in the
current corporatocracy, is at the heart of the crisis of the climate
change movement. Behind closed doors, the organizations manipulating and
exploiting 10:10:10 know and understand the dilemma created by their
infatuation with the corporate power structure. Yet the big greens
refuse to advance these fundamental issues. And to be fair, they can’t.
For if they were to be effective, in a meaningful way that actually
started a paradigm shift, they would quickly be cut off from their
generous ‘partners’. These groups have become barriers to the movement.
They no longer represent civil society, but stand as walls to protect
the system. They utilize the coercive tactic of inviting supposed
leaders of civil society into sanitized circles of power, and
simultaneously repress the rank and file climate movement.
Why are the big greens and compromised NGOs spewing out meaningless
targets for legislation which do nothing more than ensure a death
sentence for humanity? It is because they have become corporations
themselves. They are, in essence, subsidiaries of the very corporations
that they claim to oppose. There can be no meaningful mass movement when
dissent itself is generously funded by those same corporate interests
who must be targets of the protest movement.
Reading between the Lies
We must start turning off the faucets of the propaganda machine.
Information flows from dominate forces that keep our society passive,
dumbed down and stupefied. Humans display a universal propensity to deny
uncomfortable realities—we actively repress intelligence and reason. Big
Greens now employ marketing strategists to poll the public in order to
ensure any messaging is palatable before campaigns and campaign messages
are rolled out. This ensures the sad fact that the mainstream movement
no longer leads, but rather capitulates to the status quo. The movement
is now being shaped by marketing executives rather than activists. Big
greens simply tell the public what they (the big greens) calculate the
public wants to hear while at the same time protecting the system upon
which they (the big greens) feast. Unfortunately, for ourselves and for
our children, such denialism will ensure humanity’s certain famine - and
ultimate demise.
“The masses have never thirsted after truth. They turn aside from
evidence that is not to their taste, preferring to deify error, if error
seduce them. Whoever can supply them with illusions is easily their
master; whoever attempts to destroy their illusions is always their
victim” - Gustave Le Bon 1895. “For us to maintain our way of living, we
must… tell lies to each other, and especially to ourselves… the lies act
as barriers to truth. These barriers… are necessary because without them
many deplorable acts would become impossibilities” - Derrick Jensen 2000.
Now we have three partners slithering out of the rot of the decayed
carcass that was the climate change movement: 350.org, Greenpeace, and
Rainforest Action Network (RAN) have joined hands to sing a new version
of Kumbayah with the grand illusion of waking the dead, and anyone can
join the circle of song - provided we adhere to their guidelines. God
forbid we challenge the system for what it is - a rapacious beast
devouring humanity in the name of capitalism. Doing that doesn’t provide
the win-win type of ‘solution’ these groups and their funders demand.
Don’t begin to consider surprise actions that challenge corporate elites
and the political structure directly. Don’t be provocative. Don’t plan
for the potential need for self-defense. Don’t disturb dinner plans.
Don’t miss yoga class.
Follow the lead of Bill McKibben (350.org), Phil Radford (Greenpeace
USA), and Becky Tarbotton (RAN) and put three additional nails into the
coffin of humanity. The Earth is beyond reacting to the tactics employed
by those controlled by corporations, shared by tweets, and defined by
actions that happen on a Saturday afternoon and end just in time for the
next episode of Law and Order.
Aggressive action is required.
Mario Savio and Peter Camejo knew this. In the 1960’s they galvanized
the souls of Berkeley into a force that would not be denied, and would
not be repressed.
Those of us in the climate fight must not be denied, and we must not be
repressed.
“Who raises money to protect rainforests yet greenwashes their first
time logging? Who celebrates their 25th anniversary twice? Who has no
scientists yet sets policy it refuses to defend? Rainforest Action
Network @RAN of course.” - Dr. Glen Barry, Ecological Internet
Climate reality dictates that there are no solutions within our cushy
envelopes of political negotiation. We no longer have the luxury of
playing nice and limiting sacrifice. There is no reason for our favorite
big environmental groups to sit down with industry and hammer out a
compromise; the Earth is already screaming at us that half-measures
won’t work. There is no reason to believe that if we change a bunch of
light bulbs or recycle all those plastic bottles or rock our Prius on
the way to a Global Work Party we are part of the solution. We aren’t.
We must strive for what defeatists and their enablers deem impossible.
The science dictates a systemic upheaval that will shock us all, and we
can choose to endure, or choose to die.
The alarms are sounding. All 5 of them. And we ask you this: if your
neighbor’s house is burning, and you called 911 twenty minutes ago, and
there has been no response, what would you do? Would you fill a bucket
from your sink, toss the water on the blaze, pat yourself on the back,
and conclude you’ve done your part? Would you throw a party next to the
blaze with other neighbors, cheering the fact that they also brought
their buckets of water? Or would you realize the structure, as it once
stood, is now lost, and it is time to rebuild a better one, perhaps
resistant to flame?
None of the placating, enabling, corrupt entities herein is prepared to
tell you the truth. Most of them recognize it, as they have seen the
same science we have. They understand the deadly consequences of ocean
acidification, plankton kills, methane releases, ice shelf
deterioration, and temperature extremes; yet their agenda, cozy as it
sounds through rhetoric and repetition, does nothing to curtail this
reality: the truth will hurt.
We have no time to argue over strategy and tactics. We have limited time
(and only the planet really knows what hour it is) to implement massive,
global changes. And we have a system in place that will refuse and
refute every critical mode for the required paradigm shift part and
parcel. That leaves little choice for those of us alive today.
The carbon economy must end. An optimist should say we have until 2020
to accomplish that. By every means necessary we must bring it to an end.
We believe that requires an absolute refusal on the part of us, the
masses, to continue to participate in it.
Pick a date, and after? Don’t participate.
Attend the Global Work Party. And when you realize the effort is going
nowhere, let that uncomfortable reality demonstrate that we should
attend a Global Work Shutdown.
The truth is not, and will not be, televised. We must collectively
recognize that the solution set we must enact is far more complex than
any one of us currently believes, or can rightly handle within the
constructs of current society. Tactics that generate financial upheaval,
such as refusal to pay debts to banking institutions, must be employed.
Corporations must be exorcised through aggressive carbon taxation in the
short-term, and severed from the subsidizing bonds to governments of the
people. Criminal prosecutions against complicit individuals,
corporations, and countries must take place. The car must die. Corporate
media and irrelevant distraction must be abandoned. The insatiable,
commodified narcissism poisoning our culture must fade. As it does, an
new age of creativity and imagination must reawaken with fervor,
re-energizing both the spirit and the means of our global community.
Wake up. Tear down. Rise Up.
“Humans claim to be uniquely capable of logical thought, forward
planning and moral judgment. None of these unique capabilities are
evident in the mainstream international dialogue on responses to climate
change. The time has come to rise above primitive tribal instincts and
exercise our full human capacities in confronting climate change. The
time has come to act with intelligence, foresight and compassion for the
mutual benefit of all.” - William Rees, originator of the “ecological
footprint” concept and codeveloper of the method.
http://www.unitedprogressives.org/pages/index.php?option=com_content&view=article&id=990%3A101010-350org-marketing-manipulation-and-the-status-quo&catid=302%3Agregory-vickrey&Itemid=80
More information about the IPSM-l
mailing list